SaiGAR 2008 was the second tournament hosted by the user "SaiGAR Guy" on 4chan's /a/ board, and the sequel of the original 2007 tournament won by Berserk'sGuts. Like the previous year, it was modeled after the all-girls 2channel Saimoe Tournament in Japan, but instead of deciding the "most moe" anime girl, the Western-majority /a/nonymous 4chan crowd voted on who they thought or felt was the most "GAR": the manliest, most badass anime guy of all time of all animes released in 2007. Unlike its Japanese inspiration, the tournament was open to all genders, NOT limited to just male characters only.
SaiGAR 2008 began with the nominations on 2007 November 11 and was prematurely canceled on 2008 February 24, in what would have been day 7 of the last 16 round. At that time, six guys have already advanced to the Elite Eight: Hosaka the buff guy from Minami-ke, Shark Fujishiro and Nagasumi Michishio from Mermaid Bride, Lordgenome the lone Gurren Lagann survivor, Giovanni the Team Rocket boss from Pokemon, and Jeremiah Gottwald aka "Orange" from Code Geass.
Based on whatever information that remains today, the tournament appeared to be a complete mess, fraught with trolls, controversial matches, plus accusations AND confessions of cheating. SaiGAR Guy eventually called it quits after he can't take the heat from /a/nons anymore, and abandoned the website indefinitely.
Since this tournament, discussions about saimoe and saiGAR on /a/ steadily declined, while attempts to revive a similar contest on the board were met with either indifference or immediate deletion from the jannies. A decade after the last SaiGAR, /a/'s rival animation-themed board /co/ started their own charactertournaments, which became popular enough that it spawned spin-offs on severalmoreboards. However, many /a/ users still maintain a cold attitude towards these kinds of events and are unlikely to change their minds.
The nominations ran from 2007 November 19 to December 23.[1]
Nominate up to 5 characters
Any gender is eligible
Character must appear in an anime released from 2006 December 01 to 2007 November 30
Nominations must strictly follow Japanese naming customs: Family name before Given name (e.g. enter Itou Kaiji, NOT Kaiji Itou). This rule does NOT apply to people with Western names (e.g. Joseph Joestar)
All anime shows will use Japanese names by default, unless the anime is notable enough to warrant using its English title, translated or official (e.g.JoJo's Bizarre Adventure instead of JoJo no Kimyō na Bōken).
The ballot will use a weighted system: Your #1 nomination will receive 5 points, #2 receives 4 points, etc.
Top 144 characters with the most points qualify for the main tournament.
Among them, 16 with the most points are seeded into opposing sides of each block, and will not meet each other until the block finals (last 16).
A list of eligible anime for SaiGAR 2008, compiled by a_c_e[2]
This Wiki will take liberties on this list: edit some series names, add missing ones, and delete redundant and ineligible entries. There were a total of 201 unique eligible anime shows for this tournament.
SaiGAR 2008 participants
#
Anime
Type
Season / Date
1
Bakumatsu Intrigue Irohanihoheto
Web
2006 Fall
2
Black Lagoon S2
TV
2006 Fall
3
Code Geass
TV
2006 Fall
4
Flag
TV
2006 Fall
5
Ghost Hunt
TV
2006 Fall
6
Ghost Slayers Ayashi
TV
2006 Fall
7
Goddess' Blessing to Mamoru-kun
TV
2006 Fall
8
Nana
TV
2006 Fall
9
Negima!? (Negima! retelling)
TV
2006 Fall
10
Pumpkin Scissors
TV
2006 Fall
11
Red Garden
TV
2006 Fall
12
Shonen Onmyoji
TV
2006 Fall
13
The Galaxy Railways S2
TV
2006 Fall
14
Tokyo Tribes
TV
2006 Fall
15
Afro Samurai
TV
2007 Winter
16
Bakegyamon
TV
2007 Winter
17
Deltora Quest
TV
2007 Winter
18
Dinosaur King
TV
2007 Winter
19
Spider Riders S2
TV
2007 Winter
20
Tokyo Majin
TV
2007 Winter
21
Twin Princess of Wonder Planet S2
TV
2007 Winter
22
Venus Versus Virus
TV
2007 Winter
23
Beloved Angel Angelique
TV
2007 Winter
24
Dancouga Nova
TV
2007 Winter
25
Gakuen Utopia Manabi Straight!
TV
2007 Winter
26
Gegege no Kitaro 5th Series
TV
2007 Winter
27
Getsumento Heiki Mina
TV
2007 Winter
28
Giant Robo
TV
2007 Winter
29
Hidamari Sketch
TV
2007 Winter
30
Himawari!! S2
TV
2007 Winter
31
Ikki Tousen S2
TV
2007 Winter
32
Les Miserables: Shoujo Cosette
TV
2007 Winter
33
Master of Epic
TV
2007 Winter
34
Moonlight Mile
TV
2007 Winter
35
Naruto Shippuden S1
TV
2007 Winter
36
Nodame Cantabile
TV
2007 Winter
37
Powerpuff Girls Z
TV
2007 Winter
38
Reideen
TV
2007 Winter
39
Rocket Girls
TV
2007 Winter
40
Saint October
TV
2007 Winter
41
Shattered Angels
TV
2007 Winter
42
Shuffle! S2
TV
2007 Winter
43
Shugo Chara!
TV
2007 Winter
44
Sumomomo Momomo
TV
2007 Winter
45
Bakugan Battle Brawlers
TV
2007 Spring
46
Big Windup!
TV
2007 Spring
47
Blue Dragon
TV
2007 Spring
48
Bokurano
TV
2007 Spring
49
Claymore
TV
2007 Spring
50
Darker than Black
TV
2007 Spring
51
Denno Coil
TV
2007 Spring
52
El Cazador de la Bruja
TV
2007 Spring
53
Emily, The Wind Girl
TV
2007 Spring
54
Emma – A Victorian Romance S2
TV
2007 Spring
55
Gigantic Formula
TV
2007 Spring
56
Hayate the Combat Butler
TV
2007 Spring
57
Heroic Age
TV
2007 Spring
58
Hitohira
TV
2007 Spring
59
Idolmaster: Xenoglossia
TV
2007 Spring
60
Kamichama Karin
TV
2007 Spring
61
Kaze no Stigma
TV
2007 Spring
62
Kiss Dum: Engage Planet
TV
2007 Spring
63
Kono Aozora ni Yakusoku wo
TV
2007 Spring
64
Koutetsu Sangokushi
TV
2007 Spring
65
Love Com
TV
2007 Spring
66
Lucky Star
TV
2007 Spring
67
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha S3
TV
2007 Spring
68
Moribito
TV
2007 Spring
69
My Bride is a Mermaid
TV
2007 Spring
70
Nagasarete Airantou
TV
2007 Spring
71
Oh! Edo Rocket
TV
2007 Spring
72
Onegai My Melody S3
TV
2007 Spring
73
Over Drive
TV
2007 Spring
74
Princess Resurrection
TV
2007 Spring
75
Robby & Kerobby
TV
2007 Spring
76
Romeo x Juliet
TV
2007 Spring
77
Saint Beast: Light and Shadow Epic Angel Story
TV
2007 Spring
78
Saiunkoku Monogatari S2
TV
2007 Spring
79
Shining Tears X Wind
TV
2007 Spring
80
Shinkyoku Soukai Polyphonica
TV
2007 Spring
81
Sisters of Wellber
TV
2007 Spring
82
Skull Man
TV
2007 Spring
83
Sola
TV
2007 Spring
84
Steel God Jeeg
TV
2007 Spring
85
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
TV
2007 Spring
86
Touka Gettan (Moonlight Lady spinoff)
TV
2007 Spring
87
Toward the Terra
TV
2007 Spring
88
Treasure Gaust
TV
2007 Spring
89
Yasai no Yousei: N.Y. Salad
TV
2007 Spring
90
Baccano!
TV
2007 Summer
91
Buzzer Beater S2
TV
2007 Summer
92
Code-E
TV
2007 Summer
93
Devil May Cry
TV
2007 Summer
94
Doujin Work
TV
2007 Summer
95
Happy Happy Clover
TV
2007 Summer
96
Higurashi When They Cry: Kai
TV
2007 Summer
97
Kenko Zenrakei Suieibu Umisho
TV
2007 Summer
98
Moetan
TV
2007 Summer
99
Mononoke
TV
2007 Summer
100
Mushi-Uta
TV
2007 Summer
101
Nanatsuiro Drops
TV
2007 Summer
SaiGAR 2008 participants
#
Anime
Type
Season / Date
102
Potemayo
TV
2007 Summer
103
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei
TV
2007 Summer
104
School Days
TV
2007 Summer
105
Shigurui
TV
2007 Summer
106
Sky Girls
TV
2007 Summer
107
Tetsuko no Tabi
TV
2007 Summer
108
The Familiar of Zero S2
TV
2007 Summer
109
Wangan Midnight
TV
2007 Summer
110
Zombie-Loan
TV
2007 Summer
111
Bamboo Blade
TV
2007 Fall
112
Blue Drop
TV
2007 Fall
113
Clannad
TV
2007 Fall
114
Da Capo II
TV
2007 Fall
115
Duel Masters: Zero
TV
2007 Fall
116
Dragonaut - The Resonance
TV
2007 Fall
117
Ef: A Tale of Memories
TV
2007 Fall
118
Elec-king
TV
2007 Fall
119
Fantastic Detective Labyrinth
TV
2007 Fall
120
Forest Warrior Bonolon
TV
2007 Fall
121
Genshiken S2
TV
2007 Fall
122
Ghost Hound
TV
2007 Fall
123
Good Luck! Ninomiya-kun
TV
2007 Fall
124
Hatara Kizzu Maihamu Gumi
TV
2007 Fall
125
Hero Tales
TV
2007 Fall
126
Ichigo Ichie: Koibana Tomobana
TV
2007 Fall
127
Kaiji
TV
2007 Fall
128
KimiKiss
TV
2007 Fall
129
Kodomo no Jikan
TV
2007 Fall
130
MapleStory
TV
2007 Fall
131
Minami-ke
TV
2007 Fall
132
Mobile Suit Gundam 00
TV
2007 Fall
133
Mokke
TV
2007 Fall
134
Moyashimon
TV
2007 Fall
135
Myself; Yourself
TV
2007 Fall
136
Neuro: Supernatural Detective
TV
2007 Fall
137
Night Wizard!
TV
2007 Fall
138
Prism Ark
TV
2007 Fall
139
Rental Magica
TV
2007 Fall
140
Sengoku Gakudou Nikki
TV
2007 Fall
141
Shakugan no Shana S2
TV
2007 Fall
142
Shion's King
TV
2007 Fall
143
Shizuku-chan S2
TV
2007 Fall
144
Sketchbook
TV
2007 Fall
145
Tensai? Dr. Hamax
TV
2007 Fall
146
Yattokame Tanteidan
TV
2007 Fall
147
You're Under Arrest S3
TV
2007 Fall
148
Strike Witches: Pilot Episode
OVA
2007-01-01
149
Tori no Uta
OVA
2007-01-30
150
To Heart 2
OVA
2007-02-08
151
No Money
OVA
2007-02-09
152
Fist of the North Star: Legend of Yuria
OVA
2007-02-23
153
Strawberry Marshmallow
OVA
2007-02-23
154
Winter Cicada
OVA
2007-02-23
155
Burst Angel: Infinity
OVA
2007-03-23
156
Murder Princess
OVA
2007-03-28
157
Sakura Wars: New York
OVA
2007-04-04
158
Aika R-16: Virgin Mission
OVA
2007-04-25
159
Saiyuki Reload: Burial
OVA
2007-04-27
160
Genesis of Aquarion: Wings of Betrayal
OVA
2007-05-25
161
Ice
OVA
2007-05-25
162
Initial D: Battle Stage 2
OVA
2007-05-30
163
Tales of Symphonia
OVA
2007-06-08
164
Red Colored Elegy
OVA
2007-06-21
165
Prince of Tennis: National Tournament Semifinals
OVA
2007-06-22
166
Iblard Jikan
OVA
2007-07-04
167
Bludgeoning Angel Dokuro-chan Second
OVA
2007-08-11
168
Aria the OVA: Arietta
OVA
2007-09-21
169
Koharu Biyori
OVA
2007-10-14
170
Nasu: A Migratory Bird with Suitcase
OVA
2007-10-24
171
Armored Trooper Votoms: Pailsen Files
OVA
2007-10-26
172
CLAMP in Wonderland 2
OVA
2007-10-26
173
Kyo Kara Maoh! R
OVA
2007-10-26
174
Eko Eko Azarak
OVA
2007-10-30
175
Strait Jacket
OVA
2007-11-25
176
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Phantom Blood
Movie
2007-02-17
177
5 Centimeters per Second
Movie
2007-03-03
178
One Piece: Episode of Alabasta
Movie
2007-03-03
179
Doraemon: Nobita's New Great Adventure into the Underworld
Movie
2007-03-10
180
Sgt. Frog Movie 2: The Deep Sea Princess
Movie
2007-03-17
181
Love and Berry: Magic of Happiness
Movie
2007-03-21
182
Mushiking: Altered Beetles of Darkness
Movie
2007-03-21
183
Tetsujin 28: The Daytime Moon
Movie
2007-03-31
184
Japan, Our Homeland
Movie
2007-04-07
185
Crayon Shin-chan: The Singing Buttocks Bomb
Movie
2007-04-21
186
Detective Conan: Jolly Roger in the Deep Azure
Movie
2007-04-21
187
Inukami! The Movie
Movie
2007-04-21
188
Kino's Journey: Country of Illness
Movie
2007-04-21
189
Kiddy Grade Recap Movie 1: Ignition
Movie
2007-04-28
190
SOS! Tokyo Metro Explorers: The Next
Movie
2007-05-19
191
Highlander: The Search for Vengeance
Movie
2007-06-05
192
Go! Anpanman: Purun of the Bubble Ball
Movie
2007-07-14
193
Pokrmon: The Rise of Darkrai
Movie
2007-07-14
194
Forest of Piano
Movie
2007-07-21
195
Summer Days with Coo
Movie
2007-07-28
196
Vexille
Movie
2007-08-18
197
Evangelion: 1.0 You Are (Not) Alone
Movie
2007-09-01
198
Yes! Precure 5: Great Miraculous Adventure in the Mirror Kingdom!
All 144 characters were divided into 8 blocks of 18[3]
Round 1 is a three-way match (48 matches total)
Vote 1 per match
1st advances to Round 2
Voting policy
A match lasts from 00:00 to 21:59 UTC
Results are released on 23:00 UTC
Request a code in order to vote; this code takes about one hour to generate. Once you have it, fill it on the voting form alongside the characters you want.
NO PROXIES!!!!!!11
If a match ends in a tie, a winner will be randomly chosen
↑Cameo appearance. He is originally from Haruhi Suzumiya
↑Koichiro Ohta apparently made a cameo on Hayate the Combat Butler season 1, but this Wiki has not yet found proof that he did. If Koichiro did NOT appear in Hayate, then he should have been ineligible, because the last Gunbuster release — Gunbuster vs. Diebuster — was on 2006 October 10, nearly two months short of the earliest eligible date.
↑Cameo appearance; voice actor Shinichi Watanabe is playing as a fictional version of himself. This character originally appeared in Excel Saga.